Virtus 👊 #029: The Strength in Self-Compassion: A Man's Journey to Becoming His Own Ally
When was the last time you spoke to yourself with the same compassionate understanding that you might offer to a dear friend or a struggling child?
When was the last time you spoke to yourself with the same kindness that you'd offer to a close friend going through a rough patch? Not as a reward for some achievement, but simply because you recognized that you deserve basic human decency?
For most of my life, I believed that being tough on myself was the only path to success. I thought self-compassion was weakness—something that would make me soft and unmotivated. I was deeply, completely wrong about this.
The Inner Drill Sergeant
"You complete idiot. What were you thinking?"
These harsh words came out of my mouth far too often over the years—not aimed at others, but at myself. Without realizing the damage I was doing, I had slowly become my own worst critic, my own drill sergeant who was never satisfied with anything less than perfection. What's worse, I thought this internal abuse was normal, even admirable—a sign of high standards and serious ambition.
From a young age, I was taught that the world would show no mercy to the weak. "Toughen up," they told me. "Never show weakness," they advised, as if vulnerability was something shameful rather than a normal part of being human. The message was clear: prepare yourself for an endless battle against a world waiting to knock you down at the first sign of weakness.
So I prepared. I built walls around my emotions, developed thick skin, and created defense mechanisms to protect myself from criticism and rejection. But somewhere along this journey, I made a terrible mistake: I turned these defensive tactics inward, becoming both the fortress and the attacker.
In my effort to protect myself from outside threats, I became the very enemy I had been preparing to face—my own harshest critic, relentless in judgment and unforgiving of any perceived failure.
The False Promise of Self-Criticism
Throughout my younger years and well into adulthood, I believed—as many men do—that self-compassion was just a fancy word for laziness. I was convinced that being kind to myself would lead to complacency, to settling for less, to a life of mediocrity. The unspoken question that drove me was simple: if I wasn't constantly pushing myself with harsh criticism and impossible standards, what would make me achieve anything worthwhile?
Over time, my inner voice became increasingly cruel:
"You should be much further along in your career by now."
"Everyone else has figured this out already while you're still struggling."
"You're falling behind every day that passes."
"Don't mess this up again like you always do."
I was trapped in a cycle of self-punishment that I mistakenly called motivation. I believed this internal warfare was making me stronger, when in reality, it was slowly breaking me down from the inside.
By the time I reached my 40s, a profound exhaustion had settled into my bones. The voice of my inner critic had grown so loud that it drowned out any sense of joy or purpose in my life. I realized I was chasing accomplishments not because they aligned with my values or brought me satisfaction, but simply to silence the critic for a few precious moments before the barrage of self-criticism would inevitably begin again.
The Moment Everything Changed
It happened on an ordinary Tuesday afternoon. I was sitting at my desk, staring at a project I couldn't bring myself to finish. The familiar voice in my head had already started its usual routine:
"You're going to mess this up just like you always do."
And then, from somewhere deep inside me, a different voice emerged: "Why do you talk to yourself like this? Would you ever speak to someone you care about this way?"
The question stopped me in my tracks.
No, I would never speak to my son this way. I would never speak to a friend this way. I would never allow anyone to speak to someone I love the way I routinely spoke to myself.
So why was I doing it to me?
This simple question forced me to confront an uncomfortable truth: I had been treating myself with a level of cruelty that I would find completely unacceptable if directed at anyone else in my life. What possible justification could I have for this double standard?
The Misconception of Self-Compassion
Most men I know share the same misconception about self-compassion that I had. We believe it means:
Giving yourself a pass when you screw up
Lowering your standards
Making excuses
Becoming soft or weak
Abandoning ambition
But self-compassion is none of these things. In fact, it's the opposite.
Self-compassion isn't about lowering the bar—it's about removing the unnecessary suffering that comes with the journey. It's about recognizing your humanity and treating yourself with the same kindness and understanding you would offer a good friend.
What Real Self-Compassion Looks Like
Real self-compassion has three key components:
Self-kindness instead of self-judgment: Recognizing that imperfection is part of the shared human experience—not something that happens to you alone.
Common humanity instead of isolation: Understanding that struggles and feelings of inadequacy are part of the shared human experience—not something that happens to you alone.
Mindfulness instead of over-identification: Observing negative thoughts and emotions with openness and clarity, without trying to suppress or deny them.
Self-compassion isn't about abandoning goals or standards. It's about changing the way you relate to yourself as you pursue those goals.
The Paradox: Compassion Creates Strength
Here's what I've learned since that Tuesday revelation: Self-compassion doesn't make you weak. It makes you resilient.
When we respond to difficulty with self-compassion, we activate our mammalian caregiving system. This releases oxytocin and opiates in the brain, which reduce fear and increase feelings of safety and security. From this state, we're more capable of:
Taking risks
Trying again after failure
Learning from mistakes
Accepting feedback
Growing beyond comfort zones
Compare this to the self-criticism approach, which triggers our threat-defense system. This releases cortisol and adrenaline, keeping us in a state of stress and fear. From this state, we're more likely to:
Avoid challenges
Give up after setbacks
Deny or hide mistakes
Reject feedback
Stay safely within comfort zones
The evidence is clear: treating yourself with compassion makes you stronger, not weaker.
My Son's Mirror
Perhaps the most painful realization came when I noticed how my son watched me. Children don't just listen to what we say—they observe how we treat ourselves.
What was I teaching him by constantly berating myself? By never celebrating my efforts, only my achievements? By setting impossible standards and then punishing myself for failing to meet them?
I was terrified that I might be passing this poisonous inner dialogue to him. That someday he might look in the mirror and call himself an "idiot" with the same casual cruelty I had normalized.
This was unacceptable. If nothing else changed, this had to.
The Growth That Matters
I spent decades believing that personal growth was about external validation. I chased praise, recognition, and approval. I wanted to be seen as exceptional by people whose opinions shouldn't have mattered to me.
I was looking outward for what could only come from within.
True growth isn't about impressing others. It's about becoming more fully yourself. It's about developing the courage to look inward and face what you find there with kindness and curiosity instead of judgment and shame.
This doesn't mean abandoning ambition. It means redefining what success looks like. It's not just about what you achieve, but who you become along the way.
How to Practice Self-Compassion
Changing your relationship with yourself doesn't happen overnight. It's a practice that requires consistency and patience, especially after decades of doing the opposite. Through trial and error, I found several strategies that helped me begin this journey:
Notice your inner critic: Become truly aware of how you speak to yourself. Pay attention to the tone of your internal voice, the phrases you use most often, and what situations tend to trigger your harshest self-judgment.
Create some distance: Recognize that the critical voice isn't the core of who you are—it's a thought pattern you've developed over time. Try changing "I'm not good enough" to "I notice I'm having the thought that I'm not good enough"—this small shift creates valuable space between you and the negative thought.
Apply the friendship test: When facing situations that trigger self-criticism, pause and ask: "If a good friend were in this exact situation, what would I say to them? What perspective would I offer? What strengths would I remind them they have?" Then direct that same compassionate perspective toward yourself.
Use physical comfort: Place your hand over your heart during moments of distress or give yourself a hug. These physical gestures release oxytocin and send signals of safety to your brain, helping to calm your nervous system.
Write yourself a compassionate letter: Take time to write to yourself from the perspective of a wise, understanding friend who knows your entire story and accepts you completely, strengths and weaknesses alike.
Practice mindfulness: Develop the ability to observe your thoughts and feelings without immediately reacting to them or trying to push them away. This allows you to acknowledge difficult emotions without being completely overwhelmed by them.
Remember your common humanity: Regularly remind yourself that struggling is part of being human. Your imperfections and difficulties don't separate you from others—they connect you to the shared human experience that everyone faces.
The Ripple Effects
As I've practiced self-compassion, I've noticed changes that extend far beyond my own well-being:
I'm more patient with others
I'm more willing to take meaningful risks
I recover from setbacks faster
I'm more authentic in my relationships
I enjoy the journey, not just the destination (cliche, I know)
I model healthier behavior for my son
Perhaps most surprisingly, I'm more productive and successful—not despite self-compassion, but because of it. I waste less energy on self-criticism and have more available for creative work and meaningful connections.
A New Way of Talking to Myself
Today, my inner dialogue sounds very different. When I make mistakes or face challenges, I no longer jump straight to "You idiot." Instead, I try to say:
"This situation is difficult, but you're doing your best with what you have right now." "Everyone struggles with challenges like this sometimes—it's part of being human." "What can you learn from this experience that might help you grow?" "What kind of support do you need right now to handle this situation better?"
The old critical voice still shows up, especially when I'm under stress or facing situations that trigger old insecurities. But now I recognize it for what it is—not the voice of truth, but an outdated protection strategy I developed when I didn't know better. Most importantly, I have practical tools to respond with compassion rather than buying into its harsh narrative.
The Question That Changed Everything
The question that transformed my relationship with myself is deceptively simple yet incredibly powerful: Would I speak to someone I care about the way I speak to myself?
If your honest answer is no, then something fundamental needs to change in how you relate to yourself.
Fellow men, we deserve the same compassion we so readily offer to others in our lives. Not because we've achieved perfection or earned it through accomplishments, but because basic kindness is the foundation upon which genuine strength and resilience are built.
Self-compassion isn't weakness masquerading as self-care—it is strength in its most authentic form. It's the courage to stand by yourself when you fail, to help yourself recover with gentleness instead of criticism, and to recognize your worth beyond whatever you've achieved or produced.
In a world that often measures men by what they accomplish and how little emotion they display, perhaps the most revolutionary act is to be kind to ourselves. Not just when we succeed, but especially when we struggle, when we fail, and when we face our inevitable human limitations.
Because ultimately, we are not just the sum of our achievements. We are also defined by how we treat ourselves throughout the journey—how we navigate both external challenges and our inner landscape.
We deserve better than to be our own worst enemies. We deserve to become our own most reliable allies.
ABOUT MENQUILIBRIUM
We're not life coaches or gurus. Just men walking beside other men on the path to better.
This isn't about fixing you. You're not broken. (I’m obsessing about this).
It's about finding strength in honesty and growth in connection.
What you'll find here:
Real talk, no sugar-coating
Tools that work, not quick fixes
Brothers who get it
Know someone who needs this? Send it their way.
🤜🤛
We rise by lifting others.
Like the sunrise, change happens gradually. We're building a platform where men can find their balance, together. Your support today helps lay the foundation for tomorrow.
Early supporters will receive Founder status when our app launches in late 2025.